Lift death highlights elevator risk

By Sarah Bye
Published: 04:32PM BST 22 Mar 2010


A lift company has pleaded guilty after a woman was killed by a faulty elevator at her gym. Katarzyna Woja was crushed to death when the lift at her City of London gym fell between floors.

On the same day it was revealed former racing driver Sir Stirling Moss had tumbled down a lift shaft at his home, leaving him with two broken ankles and other injuries.

A lift accident at Tower Bridge a year ago injured 10 passengers.

Health and Safety Executive figures show four people have been killed and 266 injured in elevator accidents since 2002.

The HSE categorises elevator accidents as those taking place in lifts, hoisting devices and elevating work platforms. Another 182 injuries took place in lift shafts, service ducts, and cellar hatches.

The most common lift-related injuries are minor and may never be reported, such as trips, bumps and pinched fingers.

More serious injuries occur when something goes seriously wrong with the electrical system or safety mechanism of the lift.

Since 1997, passenger lifts across Europe have been governed by the Lifts Directive, which says that equipment must be maintained by the lift owner. Passenger lifts must be examined and tested every six months by 'competent' persons, such as members of the Safety Assessment Federation.

Domestic lifts do not fall under the same legislation and must be maintained at the owner's discretion.

Owners and occupiers of premises have a duty to ensure all areas open to the public are safe and that risk of injury to visitors is minimised.

A public place includes all locations open to members of the public, including schools, supermarkets, shops, restaurants, parks, swimming pools and even privately owned homes.

We recently acted for a client who fell when using used a lift at a London hospital.
Having gone up to the required floor he was – like most people – concentrating on looking at direction signs rather that where he was putting his feet. 

Due to a three-inch discrepancy in the level of the lift floor and the level of the corridor he fell, and suffered a broken arm.

The cause of the accident was traced back to a lack of regular maintenance and a faulty safety feature. The claimant received compensation for his injuries and out of pocket expenses.

Tell us what you think

All documents should be read and used in accordance with the terms and conditions. This document is for your general information only and is not a detailed statement of the law. It is provided to you free of charge and should not be used as a substitute for specific legal advice. If you require specific legal advice please contact our helpline on 03700 86 86 86.

What next?
Find out about making a personal injury claim
"We have to prove
who caused the
personal injury"

Richard Brett,
Team leader

Find out about making a personal injury claim
Ask a personal injury question
Call us seven days a week on:
03700 86 86 86
or request a call-back...
 Choose date

Want to send us something by post? Click on an office below for the address details:

Basingstoke

Shoosmiths
Quantum House
Basing View
Basingstoke
RG21 4EX

Birmingham

Shoosmiths
7th Floor
125 Colmore Row 
Birmingham
B3 3SH

Manchester

Shoosmiths
3 Hardman Street
Spinningfields
Manchester
M3 3HF

Milton Keynes

Shoosmiths
Witan Gate
Witan Gate House
500-600 Witan Gate West
Milton Keynes
MK9 1SH

Northampton

Shoosmiths
The Lakes
Northampton
NN4 7SH

Nottingham

Shoosmiths
Waterfront House
Waterfront Plaza
35 Station Street
Nottingham
NG2 3DQ

Southampton

Shoosmiths
Russell House
1550 Parkway
Solent Business Park
Whiteley
Fareham
Hampshire
PO15 7AG

Reading

Shoosmiths
Apex Plaza,
Forbury Road
Reading
Berkshire
RG1 1SH

Access Legal is part of Shoosmiths, a leading national UK law firm. © Shoosmiths 2010
Terms and Conditions of use | Privacy statement | Complaints policy | Sitemap | Accessibility | Contact us | Legal notice | Shoosmiths web site